Skip to content

Est. 2011ยทMicrosoft Partner ID 7033487ยทDelivery under 3 minยทSupport 7 days a week

Your vault is empty.

Review

EDR vs Traditional Antivirus: Do You Need Detection and Response Yet?

12 min read Updated October 5, 2026 Antivirus Comparisons

Fix it now

EDR is a recording and investigation tool, not a stronger blocker, and it assumes somebody will investigate. Decide on who opens the console at three on a Sunday morning, not on your threat model. If the answer is nobody, buy the managed service or stay on protection and spend the difference on the controls that stop more of what actually happens.

  1. Do the cheap controls first: multi-factor authentication on mail and remote access without exceptions, tested offline or immutable backups, patching somebody owns, and users without local administrator rights. EDR before those is out of order.
  2. Check what you own. Microsoft states that Defender for Business is included in Microsoft 365 Business Premium, for up to 300 users, and that it carries endpoint detection and response and automated investigation and remediation.
  3. Buy self-managed detection and response only if somebody’s job genuinely includes security and they have time to hunt. Otherwise you are paying for a log nobody reads.
  4. Buy the managed version if the honest answer to the Sunday question is that it waits until Monday. Sophos MDR is published as a 24/7 expert-led threat monitoring and response service; ThreatDown sells its equivalent as Elite MDR.
  5. Note the names before you shop. Sophos no longer publishes the Intercept X names – its packages are Sophos Endpoint, Sophos EDR, Sophos XDR and Sophos MDR, and it states that Sophos Endpoint is included in Sophos EDR and Sophos EDR in Sophos XDR.
  6. Skip it entirely for now if you are under about twenty staff with generalist IT and nothing regulated. Revisit in a year, with the four controls above actually done.

Telemetry only exists from the moment you turn the tier on. You cannot buy detection and response after an incident and look backwards, which is an argument for deciding deliberately rather than reactively.

If the staffing question settles it, you are done. Below is what the extra money buys, how the three shapes of purchase compare, and the readiness test applied honestly.

Why it happens

A protection-only product makes a decision at the moment of the event: allow, block, quarantine. If it blocks, you get a line in the console. If it was wrong, you get a support ticket. If something got past it, you get nothing at all, because there was no decision to record. That gap is the thing detection and response exists to close.

Endpoint detection and response changes the model by recording continuously – process launches, command lines, parent and child relationships, network connections, registry writes, file creation. When something is detected, or when you simply have a reason to be suspicious, that history lets you answer the questions that matter after an incident: how did it get in, what did it touch, did it reach anything else, and is it still there. The response half is the other addition: isolating a machine from the network while leaving the agent reachable, killing processes, pulling files, and searching every endpoint for one indicator at once.

What it is not is a better blocker, and the vendors’ own packaging says so more clearly than any comparison. Sophos publishes Sophos Endpoint as endpoint protection and control, and states that Sophos Endpoint is included in Sophos EDR and Sophos EDR is included in Sophos XDR. The prevention is the same prevention; the tiers stack investigation and response on top of it. Nobody publishes a claim that the higher tier blocks more, and you should be suspicious of anyone who implies it.

You have somebody whose job includes security

You have this one if There is a named person with time to hunt, and they can describe what they would do with a process tree.

  1. Self-managed detection and response is the right purchase and the telemetry will repay them.
  2. Agree retention with the vendor in writing before you buy, because how far back you can look is a tier property rather than a product property.
  3. Give them a schedule. The value of the console is in the hunting nobody has been asked to do, not in the alerts that arrive on their own.

Nobody is watching, and everybody knows it

You have this one if An alert at three on a Sunday morning would sit until Monday, and possibly until somebody complained.

  1. Buy the managed service rather than the console. Sophos MDR is published as 24/7 expert-led threat monitoring and response; ThreatDown’s managed tier is Elite MDR.
  2. Ask three questions before signing: what will they do on your behalf without waiting for approval, what is the response commitment, and what happens when they cannot reach you.
  3. If the managed service is out of reach, stay on protection and spend the difference on backups you have restored from in the last six months.

You are already paying for it

You have this one if The business runs on Microsoft 365 Business Premium and nobody has opened the security portal.

  1. Microsoft states that Defender for Business is included in Business Premium, for organisations of up to 300 users.
  2. Its published capabilities include endpoint detection and response, automated investigation and remediation, core vulnerability management and attack surface reduction.
  3. Turn it on and use it for a quarter before buying a second product. If it does not do something you can name, you have your answer.

The cost that does not appear on the quote is the analyst. A licence for self-managed detection and response is the smaller half of the bill in any estate where somebody actually reads it, and the entire bill in an estate where nobody does – because then you have bought an expensive log file. That is the calculation to run, and it is a staffing calculation rather than a security one.

Full reference

Protection, self-managed detection and response, and a managed service

Dimension Protection only Self-managed detection and response Managed detection and response
Blocks known and behavioural threats Yes Yes, the same protection component Yes, the same protection component
Records endpoint telemetry Minimal Yes, retained for a period set by your tier Yes, and the vendor reads it
Answers what happened after an incident Rarely Yes, if somebody investigates Yes, the vendor investigates
Remote isolation and response Limited Yes Yes, and the vendor can act on your behalf
Threat hunting across the estate No Yes, with the skills and the time Yes, included
Who watches it out of hours Nobody Nobody, unless you staff it The vendor
Skills needed in-house Basic administration Real security analysis Enough to approve an action and act on advice
Fits a business with no security staff Yes No Yes

Product names have moved, and a stale name will cost you a quote

Sophos has retired the Intercept X names from its endpoint pages. What it publishes now is Sophos Endpoint for endpoint protection and control, Sophos EDR for complete endpoint protection, detection and response, Sophos XDR for detection and response across the environment, and Sophos MDR as a 24/7 expert-led threat monitoring and response service. The nesting is explicit on Sophos’s own pages: Sophos Endpoint is included in Sophos EDR, and Sophos EDR is included in Sophos XDR. If you are working from a comparison table or an old renewal that says Intercept X Advanced, you are shopping for a name the vendor no longer uses.

ThreatDown, formerly the Malwarebytes business line, has done the same thing in the other direction. Its bundles are now published as Core Next-Gen AV, Advanced EDR, Elite MDR and Ultimate MDR Plus – names which state the capability rather than a tier word, and which make the ladder easier to read than it used to be.

The readiness test, applied honestly

  1. Is multi-factor authentication enforced on email and remote access for everyone, with no exception for directors?
  2. Do you have backups that are offline or immutable, and have you restored from them in the last six months?
  3. Are workstations and servers patched on a schedule somebody owns by name?
  4. Do users run without local administrator rights?
  5. If an alert fires at three on a Sunday morning, who sees it and what do they do?

The first four decide whether you should be buying this at all. Those controls stop a larger share of what actually happens to businesses of this size than detection and response will, and they cost less. The fifth decides the shape of the purchase: if the honest answer is that it waits until Monday, you are buying a managed service or you are staying on protection, and a console is not on the list.

What to ask a managed provider before signing

  • What will you do on our behalf without waiting for our approval – isolate a machine, kill a process, disable an account?
  • What is the committed time to first human response, and is it in the contract or the brochure?
  • What happens when you cannot reach us out of hours, and who is the fallback?
  • How long is the telemetry retained, and can we export it if we leave?
  • What do you need from us to onboard, and how long does it take before the service is actually watching?

Who should buy which

  • Under about twenty staff, generalist IT support, nothing regulated: a well-configured protection tier plus the four controls. Revisit in a year.
  • Client, patient or financial data, or a contract that requires monitored endpoint detection: a managed service, not a console you will not read.
  • Somebody whose job genuinely includes security, with time to hunt: self-managed detection and response.
  • You have already had an incident: a managed service. After a real intrusion the value of somebody watching stops being theoretical.
  • Already on Microsoft 365 Business Premium: try Defender for Business first, since Microsoft includes it and it carries EDR and automated investigation and remediation.

The thing that cannot be bought retroactively

Telemetry starts when the tier starts. If you enable detection and response the week after an incident, the recording covers the week after the incident and nothing before it – which is precisely the period you wanted. That is the one genuine argument for deciding this before you need it rather than during. It is not an argument for buying the top tier now; it is an argument for deciding deliberately, writing down what would change your mind, and revisiting on a date rather than on an alarm.

When a licence is the actual fix

If the decision is yes, name the current product rather than the one in the old comparison table. Sophos’s published packages are Sophos Endpoint, Sophos EDR, Sophos XDR and Sophos MDR, with each included in the next, so a protection purchase today does not lock you out of the step up tomorrow. Arco can quote the protection tier and the managed option side by side for your device count, and will size the base tier honestly rather than the one with the most rows. If your answer to the Sunday question is that nobody is watching, expect us to price the managed route and say why, rather than sell you a console that will sit unopened.

Questions people ask about this

Will detection and response stop ransomware that antivirus misses?

Not by itself. The protection component is the same one: Sophos states that Sophos Endpoint is included in Sophos EDR, and no vendor publishes a claim that the higher tier blocks more. What it adds is the ability to see the intrusion that preceded the encryption, contain the machines involved and establish what was taken. That is valuable, and it is a different claim from better blocking.

Is Sophos Intercept X Advanced still the thing to buy?

That name is no longer what Sophos publishes. Its current endpoint packages are Sophos Endpoint, Sophos EDR, Sophos XDR and Sophos MDR. If a quote in front of you says Intercept X Advanced, ask the supplier to map it to the current packaging before you compare it against anything, because the tier boundaries are not the same shape they were.

How much does this really cost?

More per device than protection alone, and the managed service more again – but if you self-manage, the licence is the smaller half of the bill and analyst time is the larger half, and that half never appears on a quote. Compare the total including the hours, not the per-seat line. If nobody is available to spend those hours, the self-managed option costs the same and delivers nothing.

Can we buy it now and turn it on later?

With several vendors the agent is the same and enabling the tier is a licence change rather than a redeployment, so yes in the mechanical sense. What you cannot do is recover telemetry from before the tier was enabled. The recording starts when the subscription starts, which is the one real argument for deciding before an incident rather than during one.

Is a managed service worth it for a small business?

For many, yes, and it is often the only honest way to get the benefit – you are renting the people rather than the software. Ask what the provider will do on your behalf without waiting for approval, what the response commitment is, and what happens when they cannot reach you. Those answers vary far more between providers than the technology does.

Was this article helpful?

Your feedback helps us improve our documentation.

Related articles

Review Sophos Endpoint vs Bitdefender GravityZone: Comparing Two Business Platforms Review Antivirus for Schools and Charities: Licensing on a Restricted Budget Review Ransomware Protection Compared: Which Antivirus Can Actually Roll Back? Review Webroot vs Emsisoft: The Lightweight Antivirus Question Finally Settled
โ† Back to Knowledge Base