Fix it now
Microsoft Defender is free, switched on by default and updated with Windows, so the honest question is not whether free protection works. It is which specific things the free stack does not do, and whether any of them matter on your machine. Some will. Several will not.
- Stay free if you are one careful adult on a patched Windows PC with a working backup. That is a legitimate setup and we would rather say so than take the order.
- Turn on Controlled Folder Access before you buy anything. Microsoft states it is off by default, needs Microsoft Defender Antivirus with real-time protection on, and blocks unauthorised writes to your Documents, Pictures, Videos, Music and Favorites folders.
- Understand its limit: Microsoft is explicit that Controlled Folder Access blocks writes only and does not restore files that were already encrypted. If you want restoration, that is a paid feature.
- Pay when other people use the machine, when children are involved, when you have Android or macOS devices to cover, or when a business depends on it.
- Pay if you want a person to speak to. That is not in the free stack in any form.
- Uninstall an expired paid suite today rather than deciding what to buy next. Microsoft documents that Defender goes to passive mode when a non-Microsoft antivirus is installed, so a lapsed product can leave you covered by neither.
Bitdefender Internet Security, which older versions of this comparison recommended, is no longer available for purchase; Bitdefender’s own page directs buyers to Total Security or Premium Security instead.
If you have decided to stay free, turn Controlled Folder Access on and stop reading. Below is exactly what the free stack covers, where it stops, and the five reasons a licence is genuinely worth buying.
Why it happens
Defender on a current copy of Windows is a full modern stack rather than a stub. Real-time scanning, cloud-delivered protection, behavioural detection, exploit protection, the Windows Firewall, and tamper protection – which Microsoft documents as keeping virus and threat protection, real-time protection, behaviour monitoring, cloud protection and security intelligence updates from being switched off, and which also blocks changes to the exclusion list.
SmartScreen is better than its reputation and worse than the marketing on both sides. Microsoft documents it as integrated into the operating system, checking any file an app attempts to download and run – explicitly including third-party browsers and email clients – as well as checking visited pages against a dynamic list of reported phishing and malware sites. So the common claim that it only works in Edge is wrong. Its documented gap is different: Microsoft states SmartScreen does not protect against malicious files on internal locations or network shares such as UNC paths or SMB and CIFS shares.
The real gaps in the free stack are specific rather than general. Controlled Folder Access blocks unauthorised changes but does not restore anything already encrypted, and it is off until you turn it on. There is no cover for the Android phone or the Mac. There is no household view, no support line, and no report telling you the family laptop stopped updating in March.
The machine is shared with somebody who clicks
You have this one if More than one person uses it, and at least one of them has installed something they should not have.
- This is the strongest single argument for paying, because most infections arrive through a person rather than a flaw.
- What you are buying is browser-independent filtering, ransomware remediation that restores rather than only blocks, and somebody to telephone when it goes wrong anyway.
- Turn on Controlled Folder Access as well. It is free, and it stops unauthorised writes into the folders that matter.
There are Android phones and Macs in the household
You have this one if Windows is one of three or four platforms in the house, not the only one.
- The free stack does not cross platforms. Defender protects Windows; Google Play Protect covers Android app scanning and is on by default; Apple’s XProtect and Gatekeeper cover macOS.
- A paid multi-device subscription is buying you one account, one renewal date and consistent filtering, not protection that is otherwise absent.
- Count the devices that will genuinely have the software installed, and do not spend slots on iPads.
An expired paid suite is still installed
You have this one if A product that nags daily about renewal and has not updated in months.
- Remove it today with the vendor’s removal tool. This is more urgent than deciding what to buy next.
- Microsoft documents that Defender goes to passive mode when a non-Microsoft antivirus is installed, and on some systems does not switch back to active automatically after that product is removed. Verify the state afterwards rather than assuming.
- Two full real-time engines should not run together. Some scanner-style products can be configured not to register with Windows, which lets both run; check the product rather than assuming.
One thing worth stating plainly: paying does not buy you dramatically better detection of ordinary malware, and no vendor publishes a figure that would let you compare. Any article that leads with detection quality is selling rather than explaining. Buy a licence for the features around the engine, the cross-platform cover and the support.
Full reference
What the free Windows stack actually gives you
| Capability | What Microsoft documents |
|---|---|
| Real-time scanning | Microsoft Defender Antivirus, on by default |
| Tamper protection | Keeps virus and threat protection, real-time protection, behaviour monitoring, cloud protection and security intelligence updates from being disabled, and blocks changes to exclusions |
| Ransomware write-blocking | Controlled Folder Access: off by default, requires Defender Antivirus with real-time protection, protects the user and public Documents, Pictures, Videos, Music and Favorites folders plus Windows system folders |
| Ransomware file restoration | Not provided. Microsoft states Controlled Folder Access blocks writes only and does not restore already encrypted files |
| Web and download filtering | SmartScreen, integrated into Windows, checking files any app downloads and runs including third-party browsers and email clients |
| SmartScreen’s documented gap | Does not protect against malicious files on internal locations or network shares such as UNC paths or SMB/CIFS shares |
| Parental controls | Microsoft Family Safety, separate and free |
| Cross-platform cover | None. Android has Play Protect on by default; macOS has XProtect and Gatekeeper |
| Human support | Documentation and community |
The five reasons a licence is genuinely worth buying
- Ransomware remediation that restores. Bitdefender documents Ransomware Remediation as backing up documents, pictures, videos and music, blocking the processes involved in an attack, and then restoring the affected files. Windows does not do the restoring half.
- Filtering that follows the user rather than the browser, and covers applications that are not browsers at all.
- Devices that are not Windows, on one account with one renewal date.
- Parental controls with reporting, which is the one part of the family suites that outperforms the free platform tools.
- Support and remediation help – a person who will look at a machine that is already infected, rather than a forum thread from 2019.
Notice what is not on that list: better detection of ordinary malware. On a patched Windows machine with a careful user, that is not where your money is going.
Third-party free tiers are a different proposition from Defender
A free antivirus from a commercial vendor is a marketing channel: the free product exists to sell the paid one, so features are withheld deliberately and the client prompts you. That is a business model rather than a scandal. What belongs in the record, and only what belongs in it, is this: in February 2024 the US Federal Trade Commission announced an order requiring Avast to pay 16.5 million US dollars over charges that it sold consumers’ browsing data to third parties while claiming its products would block online tracking, with the FTC’s account being that its Jumpshot subsidiary sold that information from 2014 to 2020, and the order banning Avast and its subsidiaries from selling or licensing browsing data from Avast-branded products for advertising purposes.
We are not going to generalise from that to ‘free antivirus sells your data’, because the published record does not support the generalisation. The useful conclusion is narrower: if you are choosing between Defender and a third-party free tier on Windows, Defender shows no advertising, has no upgrade funnel, and does not stand down Windows’ own protection in favour of something else. That is a real advantage regardless of anybody’s conduct.
When free is genuinely the right answer
One Windows PC. One adult who does not install pirated software. Updates applied. A browser with its own filtering on. A backup that runs to an external disk or a cloud folder with version history. No children in the house. That reader does not need to buy anything, and if the budget only stretches to one thing, the backup drive beats the licence.
Two things change that answer quickly. Anybody else using the machine, because most infections arrive through a person. And business use of any kind, including self-employment, where you need central visibility, evidence for clients and insurers, and a support contract – which means a business licence rather than a consumer one.
Which route to take, by situation
- One careful adult, one Windows PC, backup in place: Defender, with Controlled Folder Access turned on. Change nothing else and spend nothing.
- Shared family PC, or a household with phones and tablets: a paid multi-device suite, mainly for cross-platform cover and parental controls.
- Somebody in the house has been infected before: a paid suite with ransomware remediation that restores files rather than only blocking writes.
- Self-employed or running a business from the machine: a business licence, because you need the console and the entitlement.
- Currently on an expired paid suite: uninstall it today and verify Defender is active afterwards.
- Tempted by a third-party free tier on Windows: prefer Defender, for the absence of an upgrade funnel rather than for the engine.
When a licence is the actual fix
If one of the paid reasons above applies to you, Bitdefender Total Security is the tier we point most Windows households at, and it is worth naming precisely: Bitdefender Internet Security, which this comparison used to recommend, is no longer sold and Bitdefender’s own page redirects buyers to Total Security or Premium Security. Total Security is published as 1 account / 5 devices, or a family plan of 5 accounts / 25 devices, across Windows, macOS, Android and iOS, with 200 MB/day of VPN traffic – unlimited VPN is what Premium Security adds. Arco supplies Bitdefender consumer licences by device count and term, and if what you describe is one careful adult with a backup already running, we will tell you to keep using Defender.
Questions people ask about this
Is Microsoft Defender really enough?
For a single careful adult on a patched Windows PC with a backup, yes. It is a complete modern stack with real-time scanning, cloud protection, behavioural detection and tamper protection. Its weaknesses are breadth rather than quality: no cover for the phone or the Mac, no restoration of encrypted files, and nobody to call.
Does paying improve detection?
Not in a way anyone can quantify for you. No vendor publishes a comparative figure against Defender, and independent results move between rounds. Buy a licence for the features around the engine, not for a promise that it catches more.
What does Controlled Folder Access actually do?
It checks apps against a list of trusted applications and blocks unauthorised changes to files in protected folders – by default the user and public Documents, Pictures, Videos, Music and Favorites folders, plus Windows system folders. It is off by default, requires Defender Antivirus with real-time protection, and Microsoft is explicit that it blocks writes only and does not restore files already encrypted.
Can I run a paid product alongside Defender?
Two full real-time engines should not run together. Microsoft documents that Defender moves to passive mode when a non-Microsoft antivirus is installed. Some scanner-style products can be configured not to register with Windows, which lets both run – check the specific product rather than assuming.
Is Bitdefender Internet Security still available?
No. Bitdefender’s page for it states it is no longer available for purchase and points at Bitdefender Total Security and Bitdefender Premium Security. If a reseller offers you an Internet Security key, ask what you are actually being sold.
